Renting Half as Affordable as Buying

A new Zillow analysis finds renters are paying twice as much to rent than to own, as a percentage of their income.

1 MIN READ

In most U.S. metros, it is now more affordable to own a home than it was 15 years ago, according to a recent Zillow analysis of third quarter income and home value data.

It’s also now more cost effective to buy rather than rent, on average, by a pretty good margin. Home buyers can expect to pay 15.3 percent of the area median income (AMI) on mortgage payments, compared with the 29.9 percent of AMI renters can expect to pay, nearly twice as much.

However, saving up for a modest down payment can be a big hurdle for many renters. With more of their income going to rent, as well as other debt payments such as education and/or car loans, it can be hard to save for even a 3 percent down payment required by certain FHA, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac loans.

In areas where a median home price tops $450,000, a 3 percent down payment still comes to $13,500. Yet, millennials have an average of only $3,000 in non-retirement savings, a recent Demand Institute study found.

However, as renting grows less affordable and buying conditions become more attractive, Zillow expects 2015 to be a big year for millennial home buyers, who could surpass Gen Xers on their way to becoming the largest generation of home buyers.

About the Author

Kayla Devon

Kayla Devon is a former associate editor for Hanley Wood's residential construction group. She covered market strategy, consumer insights, and innovation for both Builder and Multifamily Executive magazines.

Upcoming Events

  • Build-to-Rent Conference

    JW Marriott Phoenix Desert Ridge

    Register Now
  • Builder 100

    Dana Point, CA

    Register Now
  • Protecto Wall VP Standard Installation Video

    Webinar

    Register for Free
All Events